大家揀邊張?

edwardyung

Like A... 因為A可調出B.
B如果係店家Jpg... 係走唔返去A的
到底有冇店家会出16-TIFF呢←呢樣我真唔知... 如果有, A同B对於我冇乜所謂, 都OK.

toys_madman

i like B!!!
不過我估A係自掃, B係店掃!!

bat222

多謝大家支持先，今晚開估及上埋張100% crop出來！

bat222

真心謝謝大家的意見及睇法,其實看相片Exif的話,相信大家都已知道A係自掃,B係店掃,但這裹就是有各位師兄的客觀分享及忍口唔拆穿才好玩!
為何會拿二張相叫大家幫手揀呢?是因為小弟放低了底掃很久了,同埋底掃有好多因素影響,自己點樣Scan都做不到好的效果(怎樣攪都冇店掃咁好),第一時間就想係咪自己部機較舊呢?(用緊出了十年的Minolta Dual IV,只有3200DPI)故希望換一部好一點的底掃,但又有點不捨得,因為之前很少用,亦沒有認真地跟店掃比較,所以希望在換機前盡力與店掃一拼看看結果
其實在多次測驗下,發覺最難都係調色,這次自掃是用原庄軟件調色,發覺在這方面花了不少時間,後來又試過SF,發覺這軟件的film profile做得不錯(比原庄的軟件可以減少很多偏色)看來軟件的影響也很大,甚至在微調focus後,也比原廠軟件更清晰
亦正如部份眼利的師兄早已看出,店掃的B圖係去唔返A圖的效果,但以清晰及指細程度,自掃的A圖怎樣都不能比了(圖A在自掃時因原庄軟件關係,不能去到最好效果,及後轉用SF後清晰度提升了很多,可以接近店掃了,但當要比較樹葉、沙石等的環境下,店掃的清晰度仍然明顯勝出)所以小弟都係要把風境相留給店掃吧,唔知用緊9600DPI的師兄是否同意小弟看法,還是真的換一台新scanner就可改善?

Jeansky

Dual scan 4 用過幾個月，簡直係折磨，偏色，片夾不平，慢！！之後換左coolscan v ，成個人開心晒！

gzman

Jeansky 發表於 2014-5-22 22:14
Dual scan 4 用過幾個月，簡直係折磨，偏色，片夾不平，慢！！之後換左coolscan v ，成個人開心晒！ ...

Nikon的確係民用scanner中最靚最可靠嘅。

Anderson

I am using Epson GT-X970, for colour negative, and I also found it is difficult to tune the colour before.

Recently, I bought a ColorChecker Passport for building colour calibration profile for M9 and M240. I found that it could correct the colour very effectively. My old M9 files look more natural and the M240 files have much less magenta cast.

Then I tried to build the profile with negative film. I use VueScan and set the output to Tiff DNG for the whole roll. One frame must include the ColorChecker in it with the lighting situation u want to follow for other shots. Must output to Tiff DNG as the software comes with the ColorChecker only work on DNG files.

Build a color calibration profile with the given software with the frame shooting the ColorChecker. The profile will be automatically added to Lightroom. Apply this profile to the frame with the ColorChecker, and clicking the square on it for a suitable white balance. Then apply this setting to all the frames with the same lighting situation.

It hugely shortens the time for tuning colour. I would say it look more pleasant to me.

C-hings could try try.

samfre

i like B

Lesommet

I still like A better 自然D

mayfourth

I prefer A to B.

bng1

i like.